In light of the Muslim ban, the purposeful omission of the word “Jews” from the White House’s official statement on Holocaust Remembrance Day and my mother’s 70th birthday, I am choosing to tell the story of my family’s origins today. It is a more detailed account than the one I gave on Facebook and Instagram over the weekend. I’ll give you fair warning. It is not an easy read and I struggled while writing it. Many children of Holocaust survivors were brought up without their parents sharing their story and without really talking about it all. We’ve pieced things together from relatives and accounts from other people who lived in the same town, mostly after my grandparents passed away. Honestly, I am not sure if it’s appropriate to tell here but when I tried to write about my family’s story, it felt disingenuous to gloss over the ugly parts. Plus, someone should write them down. That’s how we remember. It is now my responsibility to never forget the circumstances that brought my family to this country, to teach my children about our ancestors and to share their story with all of you.
In 1949, my mom came to America through Ellis Island. Her family was Polish but their town had been wiped out in World War II so she was born in a displaced persons camp in Germany along with many other Jewish people whose homes and families had been decimated during the Holocaust.
It’s important to remember that Jews weren’t nearly the minority back before the war that they are today. They had many thriving communities all across Europe. My grandmother was one of six children and the only one to survive. My grandfather was one of thirteen and only four of them survived. One of my grandfather’s siblings died the day the Nazis invaded their town. As I’ve heard it, Nazi soldiers walked up to the first house on the street and told the people living there to bring them their youngest son. The family did as they were told and one of the soldiers shot that boy in the head. It was a warning to the other Jews in the town to comply or risk extermination. Very effective obviously. The boy would have been my great uncle.
My grandmother also lived in the same town and was 13 years old the day the Nazis invaded. She spent the day hiding in the sewage under an outhouse with her best friend.
I did not hear either of these stories from my family. I read them in a book written by the surviving members of the town, years after my grandparents had passed away. Exactly what happened to my family next is unclear but I know my grandparents spent many years living and hiding in the forest. I don’t know if they fled together or if they found each other out there. I don’t know if they were with their parents or kids who were on the run on their own. One horrific story I found out only recently was that at some point during the war, my grandparents had a baby. One night when a group of Nazi soldiers was searching the forest for Jewish people, the baby started crying. Someone covered the baby’s mouth with their hand so that their group would not be found. Their baby suffocated that day and I cannot imagine living with that even though I completely understand the necessity at the time. I’m sure whoever did it saved my grandmother, my grandfather and many others that day.
We do not know if my grandparents were found by the Nazis during the war and put in concentration camps or if they were found after the war and put in a displaced person camp. In either case, a displaced persons camp in Germany was where they ended up. They had no home or town to go back to. They had grown up with no schooling or organized religion. And of course, they had very little family left.
My mother and her older brother were both born there so they were living in the camp for at least five years.
When America began letting in Jewish refugees, my mom was two-years-old. Her father had a relative in California who sponsored their family (only Jews with relatives in America were allowed in) and the plan was to move there. Unfortunately, he got sick on the boat over and they were detained at Ellis Island until he got better. They ended up having the opportunity to stay in New York because another relative offered him a job at his grocery store in Brooklyn, a neighborhood filled with refugees. They moved into an apartment adjacent to the store where my grandmother brought in a second income as a seamstress.
My grandparents didn’t bring my mother or her brothers up to be very religious because they feared history would repeat itself and it was best to keep your head down and your Jewish beliefs quiet. They spent their lifetime working hard and trying to blend in. They didn’t find the “American Dream” as people think of it today. What they found was freedom and safety, but they were suspicious and still suffered greatly. Many Holocaust survivors died young from the physical after effects of being malnourished and living in horrific conditions for many years. My grandfather passed away at the age of 47 when my mother was 16. My grandmother developed multiple sclerosis and was put into a nursing home at the age of 50. She was also suffering from what would probably now be categorized as PTSD. Some call it Survivor Syndrome.
I remember meeting my grandmother once as a little girl while she was in the home. She was frail and quiet and she gave me a stuffed white cat. I remember that visiting her made my mom sad and can vividly remember sitting on the floor next to my mom while she sat on her bed, quietly wiping tears from her eyes while on the phone. It was the first time I had seen her cry. I think that must have been the moment she found out her mom passed away but I’m not sure. My grandmother lived until the age of 55.
My mom turned 70 yesterday. Both her parents passed away over 40 years ago. And although my grandparents lives might never have recovered from the Holocaust, because of their perseverance, their children got to experience the freedom of America that we know today. And their children’s children. And now my children.
In 1949, my family was among the tired, the poor, and the huddled masses yearning to breathe free and the Statue of Liberty allowed our story to continue.
——————————–
You can follow me and my family on Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat and Twitter.
Moving post, Ilana. A favorite, for sure. -And Happy Birthday to your mom
Wow… thank you for sharing this, again, in greater detail. With everything that’s going on it makes me want to learn more about my immigration story. The story that I feel most for and claim to a greater degree is my Native American side, which is also painful. And it’s hard to be mixed, knowing the story of the genocide of half of my ancestors. I forget how the other sides may have been experiencing hardships of their own.
Thank you for sharing. May wiser, kinder ideas and actions happen soon, so that our country can benefit from today’s refugees!
Thank you for sharing your family’s story, Ilana. Hopefully this will help those the haters on Instagram to open their hearts and have a little compassion. (Referring to the ones hating on the insta2yearold pic about Dory yesterday. Grr!) But obviously, it is important to share because we all need to hear these stories to truly understand the depth of cruelty that the *President (I give him an asterisk like they do in baseball when they think someone technically broke a record but that it doesn’t really count. Heh.) is enacting with his ban and his appointments and his EO’s.
I want to share that my paternal grandfather fought in Europe in WWII. He was also in one of the special units that actually liberated some concentration camps. So, maybe at some point back there, my Grandpa somehow at least crossed the same trails as your grandparents, even if odds are they never crossed paths personally. My Grandpa served to defeat the Nazis and Hitler, and I cannot see how Trump can say he is making America great “again” and hen he is basically undoing things that Americans like my Grandpa worked to change! If soldiers who fought in WWII to DEFEAT HITLER don’t count as “Great Americans,” who and what is Trump referring to? (My guess is to the voices in his head and to that odd stranger he met at a crossroads one day, who promised him wealth and power if he would just sign this little contract, oh in blood, no big deal.)
I’m sorry, I digress. Your family is important, your stories are important, all of us are. My lineage traces back to the freaking Jonestown Colony through one line, and includes soldiers who fought in the Revolutionary War as well as on both sides of the Civil War. I have family who arrived from Ireland in the 1850’s, a Native American great-grandmother, a Swedish immigrant in the late 1800’s,and Spanish (as in, from the Spanish Conquistadors- I am from Texas, after all) ancestors as well. I grew up in a state largely populated with Hispanic immigrants from many different countries, not just Mexico. And I have family members of Mexican descent by marriage. I am so mad about the wall crap and the refugee bans. I get so mad I just lock up and can’t even think of what to write, except that we are ALL HUMAN BEINGS!
Anyway, sorry for my rant. I was very moved by your story. I hope you will also share more stories that you find out, like about Mike’s family, etc. Thank you, Ilana.
Ellyn,
Thank you for sharing your story too. My great uncle also fought in WWII. He ended up being killed on the beach landing of Iwo Jima. He wasn’t suppose to go back in after coming home from Germany but felt it was his duty to continue fighting.
Anyway, thank you.
I love your asterisk.
Heartbreaking. Thank you for sharing- it is important for us to remember what can come from hate.
This story and others like it need to be told, over and over, in all their heartbreak and horror. The future looks as scary and shameful as the past unless we remember, resolve, and resist.
Wow..completely heartbreaking. I don’t know what to say other than thank you for sharing.
I literally have tears running down my cheeks. Ilana, THANK YOU!!!! for sharing your family’s story. As difficult as it is to read we NEED to remember this! We need to make sure history does not repeat itself.
Happy 70th Birthday to your beautiful mother! And thank you for sharing her with us.
Wow. What horror for your grandparents to live through, and what relief to escape. hank you for sharing this hard story. I’d give you a hug if I could.
That is just heartbreaking. The story about shooting the baby just breaks my heart. Thank you for having the strength and bravery to share this. We need to tell these stories and we need to hear them.
This brought tears to my eyes and gave me chills. Thank you for sharing your story.
Heartbreaking and so important to share. This is why you need to speak your mind and stay true to yourself on your blog. You didn’t get this far to then be silenced once again. If people cannot understand and appreciate that, then they must go elsewhere because this is what YOU are about. Fight. Resist. Rise.
Thank you for sharing your family’s story. Much of our nation’s history in WWII is inspiring, but we also have a shameful past in how we treated Jews, Japanese people, and others who were seeking our protection. I hope we can do better now.
I have tears in my eyes. Thank you for sharing, I can’t imagine how hard that was to write. We must continue to speak out. Thank you for continuing to speak up when so many people are telling you to be quiet.
We cannot forget the past but we hope and pray we can learn from it. As citizens of this great country we have to do what we can to keep it great. We often take for granted the freedoms we enjoy. When we are threatened we see how fragile these freedoms may be. We have to be ever vigil and participate in our democracy to keep our freedoms and equality for all in tact. The Jews Initially could not phathom what was happening. We cannot sit idley by and wait for to things get out of hand before it’s too late. I am proud of my daughter for speaking her mind, something that often caused fear in me. Thank you for this post. Love, Grammy
Well said, Grammy Shorts! ??
Thank you for sharing this. Never again….
People on both sides of my family were immigrants not so long ago.
My great-grandfather came over from Czechoslovakia when he was just 13. He struck out on his own when he was only 15.
My great-grandmother and great-grandfather on the other side immigrated over from Poland, and then my great-grandmother had to return (presumably for money reasons), not knowing she was pregnant. Because of U.S. immigration laws, she didn’t return until my grandmother was three years old. My grandmother’s first memory was of seeing the Statue of Liberty and meeting her father for the first time.
I actually wrote a post on these stories myself: https://welleatyouupweloveyouso.com/2016/11/21/sharing-values-with-family-stories/
Thank you so much for sharing your families story with us. These stories are so important to understand so we can insure that we do not repeat the horrors experienced by your grandparents and millions of others.
Thank you for sharing this. I actually cried a little reading it.
My family only learned that my grandfather was Jewish after he passed away. We knew he and my grandmother were German. They never talked about it and my mom and aunts never met any of their extended family. My grandparents never even mentioned any of their names. They were raised with no religion in a largely Irish catholic area. No one ever really questioned it. It was what it was. When I was pregnant with my 3rd child we asked my aunts if they knew of any family names. Besides my actual grandparents names the only name they had ever heard was my grandfathers grandmother who they thought was named Zada. We did a little digging and it turned out that my grandfather was actually jewish and came over after the war as a baby with his zada (i might be spelling it wrong), his jewish grandmother. I’m just starting my research into the family history to flesh out more details. These are all stories and histories that might all fade from memory as people pass away.
It’s an honor and a blessing to read these stories. Thank you for having the courage and strength to share these words, so that future generations, g-d willing, can learn and remember and do better. I’m grateful for the strength your family had to persevere, look at the amazing people the brought into so many lives! May their memories be for a blessing.
Thank you for sharing your family’s story. What a courageous, resilient and heartbreaking journey your grandparents had. We must never, ever forget. ❤??
Oh Ilana, thank you for sharing this.
Thank you for sharing! This is a beautiful family history.
My sister-in-law turned 70 mid January and was born in a German DP camp. Who knows if my in-laws and your parents crossed paths. My in-laws also ended up in Brooklyn when they came to the USA.
You’re right, that was incredibly difficult to read. I can’t imagine how difficult it was to write. But thank you for sharing your story. It needs to be written down and remembered, to attempt to avoid more hate and suffering. These horrors need to be avoided, at all cost. They tragedy and suffering that was endured is unimaginable. As a mother, it was heartbreaking to read about the youngest boys in every house being shot or your grandparent’s baby being suffocated, to avoid the camp’s detection. It, literally, made my heart ache reading that. Your grandmother, and all the survivors, are incredibly strong people to have survived that. God bless all the survivors and thank you – and them – for surviving and telling their stories, in the hopes that we can avoid such senseless hatred and tragedy today.
Thank you so so much for sharing your story. This is such a critical time in the history of this country and perhaps we need frequent reminders of a horrific past so that the same mistakes are never repeated. As a Muslim immigrant living in the US, I have never felt this unsafe. We cannot let history repeat itself. I am so grateful to all those people who are standing alongside Muslims in this trying time. At the end of the day we chose to come here to to restart our lives and towards that end we try our best to fulfill our responsibilities to the best of our ability while preserving our faith and religious identity. This is a nightmare and we all need to step up our efforts to spread love, tolerance and respect. We need to hold our elected officials to a higher standard as well. This country’s diversity is its strength and we must not forget that.
Wow! Thank you for sharing your family’s story. It is stories like yours that help us remember what our country is and should remain to be.
Thank you for sharing Ilana. It is so important to not forget these stories and to share them with future generations.
Thank you Llana.
Your blog holds the torch of liberty high and bright.
Thank you so much for sharing Ilana. It’s so important to keep these stories alive, as painful as they are, especially in this climate. The only way we can prevent ourselves from repeating history is by knowing it and learning it. You’re doing important work here!
you should be very grateful for life now..
wish your family always in good conditions..
God Bless America..
Love from Indonesia.. :*
Thank you for sharing. There was so much loss and your family’s story reflects that. Today we can attempt to help people heal – to live alongside or in spite of their trauma. I’m so sorry that your grandparents didn’t have that chance. I’m catholic, not Jewish – but I hope that your grandparents are resting in peace because I can’t imagine anyone who deserves that more.